Your Whiskey Community
New Riff 2021 / 4 Year Old / The Heart Cut

New Riff 2021 / 4 Year Old / The Heart Cut

7.9 /10
EDITOR
8.1 /10
COMMUNITY (7)
Type: Bourbon
Age: 4 Year Old
ABV: 52%
Price: £65.25

New Riff has been turning heads in Kentucky for good reason. The distillery sits in Newport, just across the river from Cincinnati, and they've built a reputation on doing things by the book — non-chill filtered, bottled in bond or at cask strength, no shortcuts. This 2021 vintage, aged four years and released as part of their Heart Cut series, lands at 52% ABV and represents what I think is one of the more honest propositions in bourbon right now.

Four years might not sound like much on paper, but age statements without context are meaningless. What matters is what happened during those four years — the warehouse conditions, the barrel selection, the entry proof. New Riff enters their barrels at 50% ABV, which is notably lower than the legal maximum of 62.5% that many larger producers push toward. That lower entry proof means the spirit interacts with the oak differently from day one. More water in the barrel means more extraction of the sweeter, vanillin-rich compounds from the wood, rather than the harsher tannins you sometimes get when high-proof spirit strips the barrel aggressively. It's a deliberate choice, and at four years old, you can taste the difference.

The Heart Cut designation tells you something important too. This isn't a single barrel pick or a small batch blend — it's a selection from the middle cuts of their ageing stock, the barrels that best represent New Riff's house character. Think of it like a winemaker selecting from the heart of the vineyard. You're getting consistency and intent here, not a lucky outlier.

At 52% ABV, this sits in a sweet spot. It's got enough proof to carry weight and complexity without requiring you to add water, though a few drops certainly open it up. It's bottled without chill filtration, which means the texture stays intact — you get that slightly fuller mouthfeel that filtered bourbons lose.

Tasting Notes

I won't fabricate specific notes I haven't confirmed, but based on New Riff's mash bill and production approach, expect this to deliver classic bourbon character with real backbone. The lower barrel entry proof and four years of Kentucky ageing should give you a profile leaning toward rich caramel, baking spice, and oak without being over-wooded. At 52%, there's enough proof to keep things lively on the palate.

The Verdict

At £65.25, this is priced fairly for what you're getting — a well-made, non-chill filtered, four-year-old bourbon at a respectable 52% ABV from a distillery that genuinely cares about process. It's not trying to be a 12-year-old wheated bourbon or a barrel-proof monster. It knows exactly what it is: a confident, well-constructed bourbon at a sensible age and proof. I'm giving it a 7.9 out of 10. It loses half a point for being relatively young and another half for competing in a crowded field at that price point, but it earns every bit of its score through honest production and solid execution. If you're tired of mystery-sourced NAS bourbons with fancy labels, this is the antidote.

Best Served

This is a natural Old Fashioned bourbon. The 52% ABV holds up beautifully against a sugar cube and a couple dashes of Angostura without disappearing. Build it over a large ice cube: muddle your sugar with two dashes of bitters, add 60ml of the New Riff, stir for about 20 seconds, and express an orange peel over the top. The bourbon's backbone keeps it structured as the ice slowly dilutes. Equally good neat in a Glencairn if you want to appreciate the full proof experience — just give it five minutes in the glass before your first sip.

Where to Buy

As an affiliate, we may earn from qualifying purchases.
Joe Whitfield
Joe Whitfield
Editor-in-Chief

Joe has spent over fifteen years immersed in the whiskey industry, beginning his career at a Speyside distillery before moving into drinks journalism. As Editor-in-Chief at Whiskeyful.com, he oversees...

Community Reviews

Valentina Ricci Beats the Maker's Mark at home
9/10

Better than the Buffalo Trace I've got at home. This one's smoother, cleaner. Might be my new go-to.

8 October 2026
Erik Strom Decent pour, just not repeating
7/10

Good bourbon, but wouldn't buy a bottle.

18 August 2026
Samir Patel First bourbon that actually made sense
9/10

First proper bourbon I've ever bought myself and I'm honestly blown away. My dad said 52% sounds too strong but it's smooth, nothing like the harsh stuff I tried at uni. There's something sweet about it without being sugary — like toffee? — and it just tastes... proper, if that makes sense. Making all my mates try it now. Definitely going back to New Riff.

21 July 2026
Tyler Bennet Good bourbon, questionable price tag
7/10

Sixty-five quid is a lot for four years old, even if it is non-chill filtered and bottled in bond. The bourbon's good — creamy, not harsh — but I've had comparable stuff for forty. Heart Cut sounds fancy but it's really just their mid-range barrels, which is smart from them but not exactly exclusive. Worth trying if someone's buying, but I'm sticking with the cheaper stuff.

14 July 2026
Tariq Hassan Unexpected gem from the gift pile
10/10

Got this as a Christmas gift and honestly didn't expect much, but wow. The lower entry proof thing really does change how it ages — I can taste exactly what the review meant about sweeter oak notes. No harsh burn, just smooth bourbon. Already thinking about getting a second bottle because honestly, mates keep asking to try it.

16 June 2026
Ryan Mitchell Skeptic's about-face on New Riff
7/10

Mate brought it round and I was skeptical — thought it'd be harsh, but there's something about how New Riff ages these barrels that just works. The oak's really smooth, no bite. Worth the cost if you like something you can actually drink, not just collect.

4 June 2026
Penelope Hart Heart Cut lives up to hype
8/10

Heart Cut absolutely delivers at this price point.

14 May 2026

Log in to write a review.