Your Whiskey Community
Old Williamsburg Sour Mash Whiskey Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Old Williamsburg Sour Mash Whiskey Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

7.5 /10
EDITOR
7.5 /10
COMMUNITY (8)
Type: Bourbon
ABV: 40%
Price: £36.50

Old Williamsburg Sour Mash Whiskey Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey — that's a mouthful of a name, but it tells you almost everything you need to know before you even crack the seal. This is a Kentucky Straight Bourbon, which under American whiskey law means it's been distilled from at least 51% corn, aged in new charred oak barrels, and spent a minimum of two years maturing in the state of Kentucky. The 'sour mash' designation refers to the production method where a portion of previously fermented mash is added to the new batch, much like a sourdough starter — it keeps the fermentation consistent from batch to batch and contributes to a rounder, more predictable flavour profile.

At 40% ABV, this sits right at the legal minimum for bourbon, which is actually a deliberate choice that works in its favour for a certain kind of drinker. You're not going to get the barrel-proof punch that some bourbon enthusiasts chase, but what you will get is approachability. This is a bourbon that doesn't ask you to work for it.

Tasting Notes

I won't pretend to break this down into a forensic nosing exercise — what I will say is that Old Williamsburg delivers exactly what the style promises. As a NAS (no age statement) Kentucky Straight Bourbon at this price point, you should expect the classic bourbon signatures: caramel sweetness from the corn-heavy mashbill, vanilla and char from the new oak, and that characteristic warmth that sour mash processing brings to the mid-palate. It's not trying to be complicated, and that's perfectly fine. Not every bourbon needs to be a 12-year single barrel experience. Sometimes you want something honest and drinkable, and Old Williamsburg fits that brief.

The Verdict

At £36.50, Old Williamsburg occupies a competitive spot in the market. You're paying a fair price for a genuine Kentucky Straight Bourbon — not a sourced mystery blend, not a flavoured whiskey masquerading as the real thing. The sour mash process gives it a consistency that I appreciate, especially at this tier. You know what you're getting bottle to bottle, and what you're getting is solid.

I'm giving this a 7.5 out of 10. It doesn't reinvent anything, but it executes the fundamentals well. This is a dependable, well-made bourbon that punches right where its price tag suggests it should. If you're building a home bar or looking for a daily sipper that won't break the bank, Old Williamsburg deserves a spot on your shelf. It does exactly what it says on the label — no more, no less — and in a market full of overpriced hype, there's real value in that kind of straightforwardness.

Best Served

This bourbon was practically built for an Old Fashioned. The 40% ABV means it won't overpower the drink, and those classic caramel-vanilla bourbon notes play beautifully with a sugar cube, a few dashes of Angostura bitters, and an orange peel expressed over the top. If you're mixing at home and want a bourbon that lets the cocktail shine without demanding attention, Old Williamsburg is a smart choice. On warmer evenings, try it in a simple Whiskey Sour — two parts bourbon, one part fresh lemon juice, three-quarters part simple syrup, shaken hard with ice. The sour mash character holds up nicely against the citrus. And if you prefer it neat or with a splash of water, there's no shame in that either. At this proof, it's an easy, uncomplicated pour.

Where to Buy

As an affiliate, we may earn from qualifying purchases.
Joe Whitfield
Joe Whitfield
Editor-in-Chief

Joe has spent over fifteen years immersed in the whiskey industry, beginning his career at a Speyside distillery before moving into drinks journalism. As Editor-in-Chief at Whiskeyful.com, he oversees...

Community Reviews

Aiko Tanaka Good but not worth the premium
6/10

£36.50 feels steep for a NAS without the proof punch. Decent, but I'd wait for a sale.

11 October 2026
Andre Dubois Nice filler between the good stuff
6/10

Nothing wrong with it, but after four pints I forget which glass it came from.

2 September 2026
Aria Kim Pleasantly surprised, stopped being a snob
8/10

I was snobbish about the price. Proved me wrong though—smooth and warm, no burn.

28 August 2026
Rosa Paredes The perfect table-rounder
8/10

Rounds the table brilliantly. Everyone's happy, no arguments, proper sessionable.

6 August 2026
Priscilla Nunes Reliable, consistent, worth the shelf space
8/10

Got it on a whim because I collect the classic bourbons. Honest stuff—nothing fancy on the label but the sour mash handling keeps it consistent pour to pour. Worth the shelf space.

26 July 2026
Dmitri Volkov Tastes like I saved right
8/10

Saved three months of bar money for this. Worth every penny, tastes like comfort.

12 July 2026
Ravi Krishnan They still know what they're doing
8/10

They haven't lost their touch, still reliable.

20 May 2026
Jackson Wu Better than my usual pour
8/10

Better than the Maker's I usually buy.

29 April 2026

Log in to write a review.