Expert reviews and tasting notes from our team of reviewers
297 reviews found
Review
Bruichladdich's unpeated 10 Year Old in a pocket-friendly 20cl format delivers serious Islay character at 50% ABV withou...
Read more
Joe Whitfield
January 15, 2026
Review
A 1979 Port Ellen bottled by Signatory at cask strength from a sherry cask — 23 years of Islay peat and dried-fruit rich...
Read more Joe Whitfield
January 15, 2026
Review
A 1976 single cask Ardbeg bottled at natural strength for the 2004 Islay Festival — twenty-seven years of coastal histor...
Read more Joe Whitfield
January 14, 2026
Review
A 1974-vintage Ardbeg bottled by Gordon & MacPhail after nearly three decades in cask — rare, irreplaceable Islay malt t...
Read more Joe Whitfield
January 13, 2026
Review
A vanishingly rare 1967 Ardbeg, matured for thirty years in a single dark Oloroso sherry cask and bottled at cask streng...
Read more Joe Whitfield
January 11, 2026
Review
Ardbeg 1976 Cask #2392 is a commanding single sherry cask from the Committee Reserve, bottled at 55% ABV — a rare piece ...
Read more Joe Whitfield
January 11, 2026
Review
A 1981 Caol Ila drawn from first-fill cask #282 after twenty-one years delivers the quiet authority Islay's undersung gi...
Read more Joe Whitfield
January 10, 2026
Review
A 23-year-old Port Ellen from sherry cask 5538, bottled by Wilson & Morgan in 2002 — genuine Islay character shaped by p...
Read more Joe Whitfield
January 9, 2026
Review
A young Port Ellen from the year the distillery closed, bottled by The Cooper's Choice at 43% — part Islay classic, part...
Read more Joe Whitfield
January 9, 2026
Review
A 1983 Port Ellen from a single sherry cask, bottled at 46% after twenty-six years — closed-distillery Islay at its most...
Read more Joe Whitfield
January 8, 2026
Review
A 1994 Royal Warrant bottling of Laphroaig 10 — a time capsule from Islay's golden era that carries genuine collector ap...
Read more Joe Whitfield
January 8, 2026
Review
A 1990 Manager's Dram from Caol Ila, matured fifteen years in sherry cask and bottled at a commanding 63% ABV — a rare p...
Read more Joe Whitfield
January 6, 2026