Expert reviews and tasting notes from our team of reviewers
197 reviews found
Review
A Dutch rye finished in ratafia casks from independent bottler Dumangin — distinctive, well-balanced at 46%, and exactly...
Read more
Ash Carrington
March 2, 2026
Review
Catoctin Creek's Barrel Select Rye with a Madeira cask finish is a cask strength American rye with genuine ambition — th...
Read more Ash Carrington
March 1, 2026
Review
Laws Whiskey House San Luis Valley Straight Rye Bonded (Batch 3) is a solid, reliable pour with enough personality to ke...
Read more Ash Carrington
February 28, 2026
Review
Pursuit United Rye delivers real quality and genuine character. A whiskey that rewards attention and justifies its place...
Read more Ash Carrington
February 28, 2026
Review
The Beverly High Rye is a solid, reliable pour with enough personality to keep things interesting. Here is what we made ...
Read more Ash Carrington
February 28, 2026
Review
Our honest assessment of Catoctin Creek Rye Whiskies Review: Roundstone Single Barrel & Distillers Edition — what works,...
Read more Ash Carrington
February 28, 2026
Review
Crater Lake Estate Rye delivers real quality and genuine character. A whiskey that rewards attention and justifies its p...
Read more Ash Carrington
February 28, 2026
Review
Our honest assessment of Brush Creek Distillery Railroad Rye Review — what works, what does not, and whether it belongs ...
Read more Ash Carrington
February 28, 2026
Review
WhistlePig Double Malt 18 Year Rye is an exceptional find — one of those bottles that genuinely earns its reputation. He...
Read more Ash Carrington
February 28, 2026
Review
High West Rendezvous Rye delivers real quality and genuine character. A whiskey that rewards attention and justifies its...
Read more Ash Carrington
February 28, 2026
Review
Chicken Cock Island Rooster Rum Barrel Rye delivers real quality and genuine character. A whiskey that rewards attention...
Read more Ash Carrington
February 28, 2026
Review
Blackened Rye the Lightning is an exceptional find — one of those bottles that genuinely earns its reputation. Here is o...
Read more Ash Carrington
February 28, 2026