Expert reviews and tasting notes from our team of reviewers
223 reviews found
Review
Rye from the restored Old Taylor castle — estate-distilled and showing the early promise of a historic distillery reborn...
Read more
Ash Carrington
April 10, 2026
Review
Sweet mash rye at barrel proof — Kentucky Peerless's spicy counterpart to their acclaimed bourbon.
Read more Ash Carrington
April 10, 2026
Review
Rendezvous Rye finished in port and French oak — a seasonal release that has become one of America's most coveted whiske...
Read more Ash Carrington
April 10, 2026
Review
Barrel-proof Sazerac rye — one of the finest American whiskeys ever made, and the BTAC's most consistent star.
Read more Ash Carrington
April 10, 2026
Review
Triple-finished rye in Martinique rum, apricot brandy and Madeira casks — wildly ambitious and wildly successful.
Read more Ash Carrington
April 10, 2026
Review
Sweet mash Kentucky rye — clean, spicy and bottled in bond with scientific precision.
Read more Ash Carrington
April 10, 2026
Review
Illinois rye with genuine grain character — spicy, peppery and crafted with care.
Read more Ash Carrington
April 10, 2026
Review
Maryland rye reborn — a blend of two mash bills reviving the state's pre-Prohibition whiskey heritage.
Read more Ash Carrington
April 10, 2026
Review
Rendezvous Rye finished in port and French oak — a decadent winter ritual bottled by High West for the long dark evening...
Read more Ash Carrington
April 10, 2026
Review
A blend of straight rye whiskies finished in vermouth and Syrah barrels — a cowboy's toast with a sommelier's accent.
Read more Ash Carrington
April 10, 2026
Review
The first rye whiskey distilled at Castle & Key's resurrected Frankfort distillery — the old E.H. Taylor site brought ba...
Read more Ash Carrington
April 10, 2026
Review
New Riff's rye reimagined with 100% malted rye — nuttier, sweeter and more characterful than its unmalted sibling.
Read more Ash Carrington
April 10, 2026
