There is much to be said for a rye whiskey that knows exactly what it is. Ezra Brooks 99 Proof Rye, from Lux Row Distillers, arrives at $24.99 with a 51% rye mash bill and 49.5% ABV. It does not pretend to be something extraordinary — and that honesty is, in its own way, rather refreshing.
Appearance
Straw-coloured with medium-quick legs in the glass. Nothing dramatic, but perfectly presentable for a spirit in this price range.
Nose
A soft nose with unmistakable alcohol esters that announce the proof without being aggressive. Beyond those, you will find a perfumed rye quality with clove that rolls into something reminiscent of bread pudding. It is an inviting if uncomplicated introduction.
Palate
Billowing notes of almond extract arrive first, tingling the cheeks with a sensation that persists throughout the tasting. For a 51% rye mash bill, this is surprisingly robust without becoming harsh — a quality that deserves recognition. The mouthfeel trends toward the watery side, with a light pop in the cheeks. White sugar sweetness mingles with rye berries throughout, though nothing truly overpowers or demands attention.
Finish
Sweet with soft grassy notes appearing here and there. It fades gently and without fuss.
Verdict
Ezra Brooks 99 Proof Rye is a serviceable whiskey that competes admirably in its price bracket. You will not find complexity or depth that warrants extended contemplation, but that is not the point. This is a rye built for cocktails and campfires — a capable workhorse that performs reliably whenever called upon. At under $25, it is worth a look for anyone seeking a dependable everyday rye. A solid 7 out of 10.
