Your Whiskey Community
Wilderness Trail Settlers Select Barrel Proof Rye

Wilderness Trail Settlers Select Barrel Proof Rye

7.7 /10
EDITOR
8.8 /10
COMMUNITY (6)
Type: Rye
ABV: 52%
Price: £79.75

Wilderness Trail Settlers Select Barrel Proof Rye is a Rye whisky. ABV: 52%. Our expert rating is 7.7/10. community average is 8.8/10 from 6 reviews.

Where to Buy

As an affiliate, we may earn from qualifying purchases.

Expert Review

7.7/10

Wilderness Trail's Settlers Select Barrel Proof Rye delivers honest, uncut rye character at a manageable 52% ABV. A well-priced barrel proof option that earns its place on any working whiskey shelf.

Ash Carrington
Ash Carrington Reviews Editor
Read Full Review

Community Reviews

6 reviews
Jason Steel — Random find, now permanent
10/10

Grabbed this randomly at the off-licence and it's become my go-to. The bottle sits nice on the shelf, proper barrel proof strength without the burn. Tastes like someone actually cared about which barrels made the cut.

24 September 2026
Sophia Laurent — Honest pour for company
9/10

Works brilliantly when mates come over. You can pour it neat and no one's complaining, but it's forgiving enough with a splash of water too. At £79.75, you're not being stingy, and it shows.

2 August 2026
Jake Morrison — Wilderness Trail nails it
8/10

Wilderness Trail keeps impressing me. This Settlers Select lives up to the name — you can taste the curation in every pour. The 52% doesn't feel like a compromise; it feels intentional. Exactly what I wanted from them.

10 July 2026
Oscar Delgado — Friday night rye
7/10

Not bad for a Friday night. The barrel proof hits you at 52%, but it's smooth enough for a night out. Spicy finish works with the price tag, though I've had better ryes at this money.

8 July 2026
Rosa Paredes — Finally, a rye that works
10/10

First decent rye I've tried. This is what rye should taste like — punchy and smooth at the same time.

5 May 2026
James Okafor — Collectable and drinkable
9/10

Cracking bottle for the collection. Proof point's strong enough to age well, and the label photographs beautifully.

5 May 2026
Tried this whisky? Log in to review