Your Whiskey Community
Tomintoul 2005 / 17 Year Old / Pedro Ximenez Finish Speyside Whisky

Tomintoul 2005 / 17 Year Old / Pedro Ximenez Finish Speyside Whisky

8.1 /10
EDITOR
8.2 /10
COMMUNITY (6)
Type: Single Malt
Age: 17 Year Old
ABV: 46%
Price: £132.00

Tomintoul 2005 / 17 Year Old / Pedro Ximenez Finish Speyside Whisky is a Single Malt whisky. ABV: 46%. Age: 17 Year Old. Our expert rating is 8.1/10. community average is 8.2/10 from 6 reviews.

Where to Buy

As an affiliate, we may earn from qualifying purchases.

Expert Review

8.1/10

Tomintoul's 17 Year Old PX finish is a quietly impressive Speyside single malt — well-aged, generously finished, and bottled at a strength that lets the spirit speak. At £132, it offers genuine substance over flash.

Duncan Cairns
Duncan Cairns Senior Whisky Reviewer
Read Full Review

Community Reviews

6 reviews
Herbert Muller — Hooked for life
10/10

This is absolutely amazing. Doesn't taste like I thought whisky would, but that's a good thing.

6 September 2026
Maxwell Green — Perfect present
8/10

Brilliant gift. No complaints whatsoever.

4 July 2026
Tomas Rivera — Proved me entirely wrong
9/10

Didn't expect much. Absolutely converted.

8 June 2026
Isla McCallister — Nice, but not worth holding
6/10

Had this for a year now and it's decent, but feels like Tomintoul's just riding the Speyside name. The PX finish is there, sure, but it never really sings. Priced at £132 for what amounts to a well-made but unambitious dram. Worth shelf space? Maybe not.

7 June 2026
Yuki Nakamura — Finally got round to it
8/10

Worth every penny. That sherry finish is proper lush, and it's smooth as anything for the age.

14 May 2026
Hannah Brooks — Good whisky, wrong price tag
8/10

Decent whisky, dodgy price tag.

23 April 2026
Tried this whisky? Log in to review