Your Whiskey Community
Macallan 1874 Replica Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky

Macallan 1874 Replica Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky

8.3 /10
EDITOR
7.3 /10
COMMUNITY (4)
Type: Single Malt
ABV: 45%
Price: £1500.00

Macallan 1874 Replica Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky is a Single Malt whisky. ABV: 45%. Our expert rating is 8.3/10. community average is 7.3/10 from 4 reviews.

Where to Buy

As an affiliate, we may earn from qualifying purchases.

Expert Review

8.3/10

The Macallan 1874 Replica is an ambitious and now-discontinued Speyside single malt that attempts to recreate the character of whisky from 1874. At 45% ABV and £2,000, it is a serious collector's piece that rewards contemplation — scoring 8.3/10 for its craftsmanship and quiet confidence.

Duncan Cairns
Duncan Cairns Senior Whisky Reviewer
Read Full Review

Community Reviews

4 reviews
Daniel Oyama — Proper sherry influence here
8/10

Better than the standard 18yo I had last month. More complex, proper sherry influence you can taste. 45% hits the sweet spot — not brutal, doesn't need diluting. Nearly three grand though...

30 September 2026
Sara Lindstrom — Converted the skeptic
6/10

Thought it'd be pretentious nonsense. Actually quite nice though. Still mad expensive for what it is.

24 August 2026
Natasha Volkov — Gambled and won
8/10

Got it for my mate's birthday. Took a gamble on the pricetag but he absolutely loved it.

25 July 2026
Devon Marsh — Fancy whisky, finally sorted
7/10

Never had anything this fancy before. Tastes sophisticated, warming, bit of sweetness I didn't expect. Price made me nervous but honestly, now I get what the fuss is about.

27 May 2026
Tried this whisky? Log in to review