Your Whiskey Community
Catoctin Creek Barrel Select Rye Madeira Finish American Rye Whiskey

Catoctin Creek Barrel Select Rye Madeira Finish American Rye Whiskey

8 /10
EDITOR
8.4 /10
COMMUNITY (8)
Type: Rye
ABV: 58.5%
Price: £79.95

Catoctin Creek Barrel Select Rye Madeira Finish American Rye Whiskey is a Rye whisky. ABV: 58.5%. Our expert rating is 8/10. community average is 8.4/10 from 8 reviews.

Where to Buy

As an affiliate, we may earn from qualifying purchases.

Expert Review

8/10

Catoctin Creek's Barrel Select Rye with a Madeira cask finish is a cask strength American rye with genuine ambition — the fortified wine influence pairs smartly with rye's natural spice, and at £79.95 it holds its own against pricier Kentucky competition.

Ash Carrington
Ash Carrington Reviews Editor
Read Full Review

Community Reviews

8 reviews
Aria Kim — Didn't expect to love it
9/10

Sister bought this knowing I'd probably hate it. Turns out I was wrong. Cracking stuff.

23 August 2026
Isla McCallister — Grabbed it blind and won it
10/10

Honestly didn't know what I was buying, just loved the label. The 58.5% strength proper knocked me sideways in the best way. That Madeira finish is something else — dried fruit and spice all at once. Absolute steal.

21 August 2026
Natasha Volkov — Madeira finish won me over
10/10

Right, I was convinced craft American rye was all hype. Tried this at a mate's. The cask strength really showcases what they're doing — that Madeira wood brings this nutty sweetness I didn't expect. Can't argue with the result.

13 August 2026
Dmitri Volkov — Terrifying but brilliant
8/10

First time I've had anything this strong — the bottle says 58.5% and that made me nervous. But it's smooth enough that you almost forget. Definitely going again, just maybe with a mate to steady the hand.

15 July 2026
Gianluca Ferro — Solid dram, bit steep
7/10

Good enough to order again, but nearly eighty quid? Bit of a stretch. Still, beats most of what's on tap.

14 July 2026
Ingrid Holm — Collector's cask strength
8/10

At 58.5%, this is serious stuff, and the barrel selection shows care. The Madeira cask work lifts it above the standard. Definitely earns its spot.

11 June 2026
Hannah Brooks — Rounds hit different with this
8/10

Shared it, everyone went quiet. Does the job.

10 June 2026
Victor Osei — Good but not worth the markup
7/10

Great rye, but my usual is better value.

5 May 2026
Tried this whisky? Log in to review