Catoctin Creek Barrel Select Rye Madeira Finish American Rye Whiskey
Catoctin Creek Barrel Select Rye Madeira Finish American Rye Whiskey is a Rye whisky. ABV: 58.5%. Our expert rating is 8/10. community average is 8.4/10 from 8 reviews.
Where to Buy
As an affiliate, we may earn from qualifying purchases.Expert Review
8/10Catoctin Creek's Barrel Select Rye with a Madeira cask finish is a cask strength American rye with genuine ambition — the fortified wine influence pairs smartly with rye's natural spice, and at £79.95 it holds its own against pricier Kentucky competition.
Community Reviews
8 reviewsSister bought this knowing I'd probably hate it. Turns out I was wrong. Cracking stuff.
23 August 2026Honestly didn't know what I was buying, just loved the label. The 58.5% strength proper knocked me sideways in the best way. That Madeira finish is something else — dried fruit and spice all at once. Absolute steal.
21 August 2026Right, I was convinced craft American rye was all hype. Tried this at a mate's. The cask strength really showcases what they're doing — that Madeira wood brings this nutty sweetness I didn't expect. Can't argue with the result.
13 August 2026First time I've had anything this strong — the bottle says 58.5% and that made me nervous. But it's smooth enough that you almost forget. Definitely going again, just maybe with a mate to steady the hand.
15 July 2026Good enough to order again, but nearly eighty quid? Bit of a stretch. Still, beats most of what's on tap.
14 July 2026At 58.5%, this is serious stuff, and the barrel selection shows care. The Madeira cask work lifts it above the standard. Definitely earns its spot.
11 June 2026Shared it, everyone went quiet. Does the job.
10 June 2026Great rye, but my usual is better value.
5 May 2026