Your Whiskey Community
Stones of Stenness 2014 / 9 Year Old / Bourbon Cask / Single Cask Nation Island Whisky

Stones of Stenness 2014 / 9 Year Old / Bourbon Cask / Single Cask Nation Island Whisky

7.9 /10
EDITOR
7.6 /10
COMMUNITY (5)
Type: Single Malt
Age: 9 Year Old
ABV: 58.8%
Price: £72.75

There is something quietly thrilling about a whisky that wears its geography so openly. Stones of Stenness — named, of course, for that extraordinary Neolithic monument on Orkney's windswept isthmus — is a 9-year-old single malt drawn from a single bourbon cask by the independent bottlers at Single Cask Nation. Bottled at a commanding 58.8% ABV with no chill filtration and no added colour, this is whisky presented with minimal interference, exactly as it left the wood.

The distillery behind this release remains officially unconfirmed, which is common enough with independent Orkney bottlings where non-disclosure agreements keep the source under wraps. What we do know is significant: this is island whisky, aged in first-fill or refill American oak, and bottled at cask strength from a single barrel. That combination tells you a great deal about what to expect in the glass — the raw, maritime character of Orkney shaped by the vanilla sweetness and spice that bourbon casks impart. At nine years old, this sits in that compelling window where the spirit retains real vigour and personality without the wood having taken over the conversation.

What to Expect

Cask-strength island malts from bourbon wood tend to offer a particular kind of experience. You should expect a certain coastal salinity, a thread of heathery peat if the distillery leans that way, and generous notes of vanilla, honey, and orchard fruit courtesy of the American oak. At 58.8%, this will open and shift considerably with water — I would encourage patience with this one. Let it breathe, add water drop by drop, and see where it takes you. Bourbon cask maturation at this strength often rewards that kind of attention.

The single cask format is worth noting. This is not a vatting of dozens of barrels calibrated for consistency — it is one cask's story, with all the individuality and slight unpredictability that entails. That is part of the appeal, and frankly, part of the reason independent bottlings like this exist. You are getting something the distillery itself chose not to release under its own label, which can mean almost anything, but at its best means a distinctive outlier that did not fit the house profile.

The Verdict

At £72.75, this sits in fair territory for a cask-strength single cask release. You are paying for transparency — no dilution, no blending, no cosmetic adjustments — and for the romance of an Orkney malt named after standing stones that have watched over that landscape for five thousand years. I find it genuinely appealing. The strength is assertive but not punishing, the age is sufficient without being excessive, and the bourbon cask should provide an accessible entry point for anyone who finds heavily sherried or peated island malts too much to wrestle with. I have scored this 7.9 out of 10: a confident, well-priced single cask bottling that delivers honest island character and rewards those willing to spend a little time with it.

Best Served

Pour it neat first and sit with it for five minutes. Then add still water, a few drops at a time — at 58.8% ABV, this whisky genuinely needs it to show its full range. A half teaspoon of water will likely transform it. If you are feeling sociable, this would also make a superb Highball: 30ml of whisky over ice with 90ml of good soda water and a strip of lemon zest. The bourbon cask sweetness holds up beautifully against carbonation.

Where to Buy

As an affiliate, we may earn from qualifying purchases.
Duncan Cairns
Duncan Cairns
Senior Whisky Reviewer

Duncan has spent two decades judging Scotch whisky at competitions from the International Wine & Spirit Competition to the World Whiskies Awards, developing a palate that prizes balance and terroir ab...

Community Reviews

Grace Kim Saved three months for this
9/10

Worth saving up for — been waiting three months to buy this. Brilliant stuff, proper punchy at cask strength.

25 September 2026
Natasha Volkov Won me over at 58%
8/10

Thought 58% would be brutal but it's actually brilliant. Smooths out nicely with a drop of water, really good dram.

6 September 2026
Elena Vasquez The sweet spot
8/10

This one sits nicely between the young stuff and the heavy oak. Proper island character, worth ordering by the bottle.

13 August 2026
Valentina Ricci Better than I expected
7/10

Lovely gift from a mate. Proper whisky, bit intense for me straight but definitely tasty.

27 June 2026
Olivia Park Bit of a surprise
6/10

First time trying a cask strength and it's a bit much honestly. Really strong, burns going down. Not bad, just... maybe should've started with something cheaper. My mate reckons the 9-year age and bourbon barrel make it special but I'm probably missing something.

25 April 2026

Log in to write a review.