Your Whiskey Community
Bunnahabhain 1998 / Manzanilla Cask / Feis Ile 2023 Islay Whisky

Bunnahabhain 1998 / Manzanilla Cask / Feis Ile 2023 Islay Whisky

8.1 /10
EDITOR
8.3 /10
COMMUNITY (8)
Type: Islay
Age: 6 Year Old
ABV: 52.3%
Price: £409.00

There is a particular stillness to the north shore of Islay that Bunnahabhain has always bottled better than any marketing campaign could capture. The distillery sits at the end of a single-track road, facing the Sound of Jura, and its whisky has long carried that sense of quiet remove — an Islay malt that refuses to shout. This 1998 vintage, finished in Manzanilla cask and released for Feis Ile 2023, is a festival bottling that rewards patience over spectacle.

Manzanilla is the driest, most coastal style of sherry, aged under flor in the bodegas of Sanlúcar de Barrameda where Atlantic breezes creep through the warehouse walls. It is a deliberate and inspired cask choice for a distillery whose own warehouses sit within spray-distance of the sea. At 52.3% ABV and bottled from a 1998 distillation, this is a whisky with serious time in wood — the kind of maturation that tends to pull Bunnahabhain's naturally honeyed, malty spirit into richer, more complex territory.

What you should expect here is a meeting of two coastlines: the saline, mineral character that Bunnahabhain develops over decades, layered with the bone-dry, almost briny influence of Manzanilla sherry wood. This is not a sweet sherry bomb. Manzanilla casks tend to add texture and salinity rather than fruit and sugar, and that distinction matters. It suggests a whisky of restraint and structure rather than fireworks.

Tasting Notes

Specific tasting notes were not recorded for this review. What I can say is that the combination of a quarter-century in wood and a Manzanilla finish at natural cask strength places this firmly in the territory of coastal complexity — dry, layered, and almost certainly unlike any other Bunnahabhain you have tried.

The Verdict

At £409, this is a festival bottling priced like one. Feis Ile releases carry a premium that reflects scarcity as much as liquid quality, and you are paying for the privilege of owning something that a few hundred people on a small Hebridean island had first access to. That said, a 1998 Bunnahabhain in Manzanilla wood is not something the distillery offers every year, and the specificity of the cask choice shows real thought from whoever selected it. I would score this 8.1 out of 10 — a confident, well-conceived release that earns its place on the shelf, even if the price demands you think twice before opening it on a Tuesday.

Best Served

Pour this neat in a Glencairn, ideally on an evening when you can give it time. Add a few drops of cool water after the first nosing to open up the cask influence — Manzanilla-finished whiskies often reveal their best texture with a little dilution. If you want to set the mood, put on something unhurried. Bill Evans, maybe. This is not a whisky for background noise.

Where to Buy

As an affiliate, we may earn from qualifying purchases.
Joe Whitfield
Joe Whitfield
Editor-in-Chief

Joe has spent over fifteen years immersed in the whiskey industry, beginning his career at a Speyside distillery before moving into drinks journalism. As Editor-in-Chief at Whiskeyful.com, he oversees...

Community Reviews

Maxwell Green Worth the wait and the savings
8/10

Took me months to save up for this one. Finally cracked it open and... yeah, it was worth every penny. Smooth and complex.

3 October 2026
Elena Vasquez Changed my mind on sherry cask
8/10

Was convinced the price was madness. Tried it and... it's actually brilliant. Dry, complex, no cloying sweetness.

16 September 2026
Nils Bergman Wow, is all whisky this good?
10/10

This is incredible, never had anything like it.

11 September 2026
Tyler Bennet Solid, if a touch salty
7/10

Nice dram but a bit briny for me.

2 September 2026
Jorge Castillo Adds to the shelf nicely
7/10

Good addition to the collection, nothing revolutionary though.

22 August 2026
Aria Kim Best birthday present I've had
9/10

Got this for my birthday and couldn't be happier.

24 July 2026
Ayako Hirano Great whisky, terrible price
7/10

Lovely drop but four hundred quid is steep.

10 July 2026
Sara Lindstrom My best Islay, easy
10/10

Better than my Talisker, better than my Ardbeg.

3 June 2026

Log in to write a review.