First Impressions
Aberlour 16 Double Cask — bourbon and Oloroso sherry double maturation. A genuine step up from the 12. The newer 40% bottling slightly diminishes what was once a 43% expression.
Tasting
Toffee and caramel nose. Creamy palate of dried fruits, cinnamon, and plums. Warming finish with raisins and gentle oak. Double cask balance is the signature.
The Verdict
Aberlour 16 earns a 7.5 — solid Speyside with good sherry influence at £58. The 40% ABV holds it back from greatness. If you find the 43% bottling, snap it up.